Trang chủEsportsThe Last of Us Tops the 100 Greatest Games List: When the Rubric Is Hidden, Controversy Becomes the Product

The Last of Us Tops the 100 Greatest Games List: When the Rubric Is Hidden, Controversy Becomes the Product

Phan NgọcStaff Writer2026-10-22 22:06Tiếng Việt

1:40 a.m., Shanghai. Two screens. One carries the cut of the match I have to...

1:40 a.m., Shanghai. Two screens. One carries the cut of the match I have to commentate at nine the next morning; the other is a phone vibrating nonstop in a commentators' group chat. Kinda Funny Games has just published a list of the 100 greatest games in history. Number one: The Last of Us. Forty minutes later I have read three kinds of reaction. The first congratulates — Naughty Dog earned it, no argument. The second is furious — The Last of Us Part II is the real peak, and Part I is a safe draft that got promoted on seniority. The third wakes me up: a group puts Sekiro on the scale and asks the editors, directly, which yardstick they used. No answer. Nowhere in the entire publication is there a single line stating the weighting between gameplay quality, popularity and historical influence. That gap is the story. A ranking that hides its criteria is like a league that publishes its group-stage format but hides how ties are broken. The matches still happen. From that moment on, nobody argues about football anymore — everybody argues about the rulebook. The Kinda Funny list is the product of a creator-driven outlet, published in a 1-to-100 format. That format is nearly as old as the industry: low production cost, long content shelf life, and near-unlimited capacity to generate argument. The structure of the piece shows intent. It opens with the controversy, then reveals the ranking. Readers are placed in an argument before they know what they are arguing about. That is a familiar inversion technique in entertainment journalism, and it works — the comments erupt before anyone has finished reading the list. Three camps form almost instantly. The defenders of number one use historical influence: The Last of Us sits on a line running from primitive products like Pong to modern titles like Clair Obscur: Expedition 33; it inherits the Uncharted lineage and set a storytelling standard for a generation of studios. The attackers use systems: Part I's gameplay is shallow, Part II is where Naughty Dog actually experimented, and placing Part I on top rewards safety. A third, smaller but loudest camp names Sekiro and other titles that demand more mechanical skill. What matters: all three camps are arguing with three different yardsticks, and none of them admits it. I have covered esports since 2026, when I was a swimmer turned football analyst writing under a neutral pen name. My first piece — arguing that Hulk was SIPG's biggest weakness after the AFC Champions League semi-final against Urawa Red Diamonds — took five days to finish. Eight dribbles, two key passes; Wu Lei posted 0.4 xG while barely touching the ball inside the box. I rewrote it repeatedly because I was afraid a single data error would let people say “what does a girl know about football”. That experience taught me something I still carry: a claim is only worth trusting when the writer dares to state what they measured. The top-100 list does not. Most of the argument around it will die within two weeks. The structural hole inside it deserves longer, because it is the hole the entire esports industry keeps falling into. A ranking that hides its criteria manufactures its own controversy. Picture a football league that publishes its group format but hides the tiebreaker: goal difference, head-to-head, or cards. Every draw spawns a legal dispute. In esports I have watched this repeat dozens of times. When organisers publish a detailed rulebook, half the scandals deflate before they explode. When they do not, every ruling becomes evidence of bias, and the community starts building theories about who is favoured. The Kinda Funny list falls into the second case. The publication itself records the community's question — does this list evaluate by gameplay quality, popularity, or influence? — and never answers it. The best question in the piece is the one the piece refuses to resolve. The result is two incompatible yardsticks applied to one ranking. The defenders use historical influence: a game is great if it changed how the industry works. The attackers use systemic depth: a game is great if its mechanics are thick enough to sustain hundreds of hours. These yardsticks do not contradict each other; they measure different things. It is like judging a striker by goals and by pressing triggers: both are correct, and there is no direct comparison. This is where my trade and theirs meet. “Don't ask how good the player is — ask how the system shelters him.” I wrote that years ago about a midfielder whose goal numbers never captured him. It applies to games identically. The Last of Us Part I is sheltered by a storytelling system Naughty Dog built through Uncharted; Part II is sheltered by a far more complex combat system. People are arguing about which system shelters better, then calling it an argument about “the best game”. The safe-versus-ambitious dichotomy is this list's most durable asset, and it has nothing to do with the top slot. Critics call Part I the safe choice: linear story, proven mechanics, no design risk. Defenders call Part II the gamble: more open combat, fragmented narrative, an emotional bet. Put those side by side and you have the oldest argument in content production — iterative refinement versus experimental risk. I have seen the sporting version of this argument hundreds of times. “Deschamps was not wrong that year — the crowd's reading of ugliness was.” France in 2026 held 42% of the ball against Argentina, took 15 shots, put 8 on target, and won 4-3. The crowd called it ugly football. But Deschamps deliberately conceded the pitch and left space behind the Argentine back line — a systemic choice, not an accident. Mbappé scored twice because of that system, not because of individual inspiration. The esports equivalent is a champion who wins on stable macro for three straight seasons versus a team that invents a new draft structure and either lifts the trophy or exits in groups. Fans always reward the second and always distrust the first. History usually records the first. “The meta in esports is not invented by anyone — it reveals itself when someone bothers to calculate.” The same holds for games: the so-called design standard

The Last of Us Tops the 100 Greatest Games List: When the Rubric Is Hidden, Controversy Becomes the Product

The Last of Us Tops the 100 Greatest Games List: When the Rubric Is Hidden, Controversy Becomes the Product

The Last of Us Tops the 100 Greatest Games List: When the Rubric Is Hidden, Controversy Becomes the Product

Cầu thủ liên quan